4921 Crittenden Ave. presents an outstanding opportunity for investors, flippers, and buyers seeking a high-performing rental in one of Indianapolis’ hottest pockets—South Broad Ripple / Bellaire 
.
This 2-bedroom, 1-bath single-family home offers 874 sq. ft. of efficient living space and a rare two-car detached garage 
, making it highly attractive to both tenants and future buyers. The property features natural hardwood floors 
and major value drivers already in place, including a 5-year-old roof, furnace, and A/C 
—significantly reducing near-term capital expenditures.
Market data supports strong upside, with the lowest sale within a quarter-mile over the past year at $120,000 
, reinforcing the area’s demand and stability. Located minutes from Broad Ripple’s dining, nightlife, parks, and trails 
, this property is well-positioned for consistent rental income, appreciation, or a light value-add flip in a neighborhood that continues to outperform.
Recent Neighborhood Comps
4926 Crittenden SOLD 232k – 2 Bed,1 Bath,NO GARAGE
4965 Kingsley SOLD 235k – 2 Bed,1 Bath,1 car garage
4708 Crittenden SOLD 250k – 2 Bed, 1 Bath, 2 car garage
5158 Crittenden SOLD 260k- 2 Bed, 1 Bath, 2 car garage
